Why does a higher deductible lower your insurance premium?
Reviewed by the Skyview Auto Glass technical team — NWRD-, ASE- and DINITROL-trained technicians · Updated November 2026
Quick answer
A higher deductible lowers your premium because you take on more of the cost of each claim. The trade-off is that you pay more out of pocket when damage happens. For glass, a high deductible often means most jobs are paid out of pocket, since chip repair runs $75 to $150 and replacement runs $200 to $500+. What applies depends on your policy, so verify it with your insurer.
Is a higher deductible better
A deductible is your share of a covered loss, and a premium is what you pay for the policy itself. When you raise the deductible, you agree to pay more toward each claim, so the insurer charges less for the policy. Lowering the deductible does the opposite — the insurer takes on more of each loss, so the premium rises.
The trade-off matters for glass. With a high comprehensive deductible, most glass jobs fall below or near the deductible, so you end up paying for them yourself. Chip repair runs $75 to $150 and a windshield replacement runs $200 to $500+, while common deductibles are $100, $250, $500, or $1,000.
Some drivers choose a higher deductible to keep the premium down and accept that they will pay for minor glass damage out of pocket. Others prefer a lower deductible, or add full glass coverage that removes the glass deductible entirely, so a claim leaves them with less to pay. The right balance depends on how you weigh the premium against what you would pay for a glass claim.
What deductible should I choose for glass
Higher deductible
- Lower premium, because you take on more of each loss.
- More glass jobs paid out of pocket.
- A $500 or $1,000 deductible often exceeds a chip repair.
- Worth it if you rarely file claims.
Lower deductible
- Higher premium, because the insurer takes on more.
- More of each glass claim covered by the policy.
- A $100 or $250 deductible leaves less for you to pay.
- Some policies add full glass coverage that removes it.
The right deductible depends on how you balance the premium against what you would pay for a glass claim. What applies depends on your policy, so verify it with your insurer or agent.
What a high deductible means for glass
- A chip repair at $75 to $150 often costs less than a $250, $500, or $1,000 deductible.
- A windshield replacement at $200 to $500+ may fall near or below a high deductible.
- When the job costs less than the deductible, paying yourself usually costs less.
- Full glass coverage is an add-on on some policies that lowers or removes the glass deductible.
- Whether a claim affects your premiums depends on your insurer and state — ask your insurer.
More questions about deductibles and premiums
Should I raise my comprehensive deductible?
Raising it lowers your premium but increases what you pay per claim. For glass, a high deductible often means paying out of pocket, since most jobs fall near or below it. Confirm the trade-off with your insurer or agent.
What deductible should I choose for glass?
One that balances the premium against what you would pay for a glass claim. A lower deductible leaves less for you to pay per claim; a higher one lowers the premium. Some policies add full glass coverage. Check yours with your insurer.
Will a glass claim raise my premium?
Whether a claim affects your premiums depends on your insurer and your state. Skyview cannot predict it — ask your insurer how a glass claim is treated before you file.
Related guides
More in Insurance and claims
- Does a windshield chip repair count as an insurance claim?
- What happens if you chip the windshield on a rental car?
- Is it worth paying cash for a windshield instead of filing a claim?
- Does insurance cover windshield replacement?
- Does liability insurance cover windshield damage?
- What is full glass coverage?
Need auto glass service?
Skyview Auto Glass has 191 shops across Michigan, Indiana and Illinois, each offering in-shop and mobile service. Call us or book a visit — same-day service is often available.